©2017 by The House That Blume Built.

A Host of Imperfections

August 4, 2018

 

I recently ran into a fellow English teacher. We started talking about the upcoming school year and she happened to mention that she’d decided not to teach Shakespeare to her 9th and 10th graders. Her reasons involve being culturally competent and the Western Canon not being reflective of the students in her classroom. I don’t disagree.

The texts we use in our classroom should be reflective of the students within that classroom. I also agree that the Western Canon is highly problematic, and it needs to evolve. It needs to become living, flexible, and reflective of our changing world. My willingness to even consider that the Western Canon is worth fixing reflects my own education and bias. I willingly concede that it is a monumental task, and if it can’t become significantly better, it needs to take its rightful place beside all the other obsolete things our world has outgrown.

Here’s where I disagree with my colleague, I don’t think the authors who have become the standard bearers of the Western Canon should be banished to the dusty corners of our book rooms. Shakespeare still has a lot to teach us about language - how to captivate with it, as well as how to play with it. The answer for inclusion is not exclusion. The problem isn’t Shakespeare in the curriculum. The problem is the entirety of school curriculums and the Western Canon look like Shakespeare-old, dead, white, and usually male.

These authors have been trusted to tell every story because for too long we’ve pretended it was the only story. Too often curriculums consider themselves diverse because they’ve included books about the struggles of Black, Latinx, and Asian people, which is itself problematic because too often diversity ends with race. Indulge me this tangent.

Diversity does not end with race. It never did. Yes, we need to reflect the lives and realities of our black and brown students, but we also need to remember there is no universal black story. There is no universal Latinx story. There is no universal Asian story. Because layered within the realities of race are the realities of gender, sexuality, religion, mental health, physical differences, intellectual differences, economic differences, and on it goes. That’s diversity.

Back to my main point.

We know the problem is canon and curriculum. So what’s the answer? There are so many answers. Answers that have been shared and shouted by people with a larger impact than this tiny tiny corner of the Internet. The answers are:

1. Remake the Western Canon in our own image. Let it reflect the right side of history even though the world is currently tearing itself apart. Let’s have the hard conversations about what we teach, why we teach it, and how we teach it. Let’s ask if it still belongs in curriculums. Let’s be honest about the flaws. 


2. Choice is what students need. Not censored choice. You don’t think 12-year-olds can handle The Hate U Give. It sounds like the problem is yours. Step aside. I’ll never stop saying this.


3. Pairing those old dusty tomes with the shiny and new. Teach Romeo & Juliet alongside Rainbow Rowell’s Eleanor & Park or Bill Konigsberg’s Openly Straight or Nicola Yoon’s Everything, Everything or Ibi Zoboi’s Pride or . . . How about Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein with Dhonielle Clayton’s The Belles? The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn with The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue?

I have two challenges for you:

 

 

  • Ask yourself if what you teach is best for your students. If it reflects their lives, or does it just reflect your education? Are you upholding the Western Canon because someone told you it is the epitome of literary merit? Be reflective.

 

  • Pair texts. Let your students pair texts.


It’s time for a change, but we have to stop the nasty education habit of declaring everything we once did a failure and always believing newer means better and best. 

Please reload

Recent Posts

I Can Quit You

March 4, 2020

Avoiding Windmills and the Chase

February 17, 2020

Heavy With Mood

February 5, 2020

Please reload

Archive

March 2020

February 2020

January 2020

December 2019

October 2019

June 2019

May 2019

April 2019

March 2019

February 2019

January 2019

December 2018

October 2018

September 2018

August 2018

July 2018

June 2018

May 2018

April 2018

March 2018

February 2018

January 2018

December 2017

November 2017

October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

Please reload

Tags

2017

Albertalli

Blume

Bookshelf of My Life

Down the Rabbit Hole

Favorites of 2017

Harry Potter

J.K. Rowling

Jason Reynolds

Konigsberg

Mackenzi Lee

McManus

McMullen

Menon

Middle Grade

Netflix worthy

Percy Jackson

Rick Riordan

Sammy Keyes

The Parker Inheritance

Top 10

Watership Down

cecilia ahern

colleen gleason

diversity

john david anderson

judge a book by its cover

rules

sheila tubman

social justice

Please reload

 

THE HOUSE THAT BLUME BUILT

thehousethatblumebuilt@gmail.com

  • Home

  • About

  • More